Cabrillo Horticulture 100A - Propagation Project

Instructor: Kathleen Navarez

Peter Beckmann, October through December 2009


Project Overview

The hypothesis for this propagation research project is the assumption that different moon phases have an impact on the rooting of cuttings. These phases are defined in detail in biodynamic agriculture. Not only is the full and new moon an indication for different gardening activities, an additional role is also attributed to the the moon's position in relation to other zodiac signs, its relation to the planet Saturn, the moon's trajectory over the Earth, its relation to the sun, and its maximum and minimum distance to Earth. Depending on the moon's position, different gardening activities, such as planting seeds, rooting cuttings, harvesting, and making hay are believed to be more or less successful.

In this propagation test, I am comparing a set of cuttings and seeds planted at a non-beneficial moon day (28 September, 2009) to another set of identical cuttings and seeds planted at a moon phase beneficial for rooting plants (30 September, 2009). All the cuttings come from the Santa Cruz Mountains at an altitude of roughly 1,200 feet above sea level.

The Bird seed experiment is a side project. Since the birch is one of my favorite trees, I wanted to experiment with planting Birches from seed. The seeds come from a tree in the city of Santa Cruz, California.


Some Research History

Besides plenty of anecdotal evidence of the moon's effect on our gardening activities, there is also a wide body of scientific research available, of which I am presenting a brief sampling:

The probably best know proponent of the moon planting theory is the German gardener Maria Thun. Since many years, the has experimented with the influence of cosmic constellations on the planting and growing cycle. Beside her famous potatoe experiment from 1964 until 1971, which showed clear yield differences, Thun also acknowledges that there is much more to consider than purely moon and planet constellations. In their own potato trial plantings, Kollerstrom and Staudenmaier showed that potatoes produced a 30% higher crop yield when planted during the "right" moon phase, which confirmed Thun initial conclusions.
(Evidence for lunar-sidereal rhythms in crop yield: a review by Nicholas Kollerstrom and Gerhard Staudenmaier)

Another set of trials was conducted by Ulf Abele as part of his dissertation at the Giessen University, Germany. He compared grain crops (barley and oats) in 1970-1971, and root crops (carrots and radish) in their reaction to different moon cycles. His research showed an increased crop yield of 7 to 21 percent when planted during the "right" moon cycle.
(Evidence for lunar-sidereal rhythms in crop yield: a review by Nicholas Kollerstrom and Gerhard Staudenmaier)

The Suiss researcher Luecke conducted another set of potatoe trials from 1979 to 1980 and found a 18 percent higher yield in the crop planted at a beneficial moon phase.
(Evidence for lunar-sidereal rhythms in crop yield: a review by Nicholas Kollerstrom and Gerhard Staudenmaier)


The Plants

ceanothusCeanothus Concha (California Mountain Lilac). An evergreen shrub native to California, this genus has blue flowers in small oval clusters. The seeds can lie dormant for hundreds of years and depend on forest fires to trigger germination.

ceanothusSequoia Sempervirens (Coast Redwood). An evergreen tree native to a 450 mile stretch of the California coast from southern Oregon to the Big Sur coast. Redwood cones release tiny brown seeds when mature. A single tree may produce six million seeds in a year. Of these seeds, less than 5% germinate, and of these, very few actually grow into seedlings. Redwoods are also capable of sprouting from the roots of parent trees, from dormant buds in the burls at the base of a tree, or from fallen trees. As well, if a tree is cut or burned, a family circle of trees ("fairy ring") may sprout up from the stump. These sprouts, because of already established root systems, grow more vigorously than seedlings and so are the more common form of reproduction. In fact, successive generations of sprouts are really "clone trees". Thus the genetic information of an individual redwood may be thousands of years old, dating back to the first parent. Read more.

plumbagoPlumbago. A native to South Africa, this evergreen produces blue flower clusters from late spring to late summer.

birchBetula Pendula (European White Birch). This desiduous tree grows 30 to 40 feet high and is native to native Europe. Birches prefer well drained and sandy soils. An example of a healthy birch habitat can be found in northern Germany's Heide area ("Heide" stands for heather), where extensive birch forests are surrounded by a carpet of heather plants.

Back to top.


Project Outline

All Cuttings were treated in a 5% diluted growth hormone solution and planted in a mix of 1 part sifted peatmoss and 3 parts perlite. All flats started out with moist soil and are misted every 15 minutes. No bottom heat.

ceanothus Ceanothus Concha: Semiripe heel cuttings, trimmed back to two nodes.

redwood cutting Sequoia Sempervirens: Terminal green cuttings (this year's growth), trimmed back to two nodes.

plumbago Plumbago: Terminal green cuttings with a heel, trimmed back to two nodes.

Betula Pendula: I collected dry seed pods, extracted the seeds, and sprinkled them in a bed of germination mix (equal parts of perlite, vermiculite, and peatmoss), covered with a sprinkle of germination mix.

Back to top.


Weekly Progress

Planting
I picked Monday, 28 September, 2009 (a class day) as the non-benficial day, and Wednesday, 30 September, 2009 as the moon-favored planting day suited especially for rooting. I based the planting decision on the biodynamic moon calendar.
Week 1:
The mist bench
Week 3:
5 dead Plumbagos
Week 3: The first redwood bud
Week 3: The first Plumbago shoot
Week 3: The first Birch seed
Week 4: Happy Plumbagos

Week 4: More happy Plumbagos

Week 5: The litte Birch is growing

Week 8: The Redwoods are taking off
Week 10: The first Ceanothus root

Back to top.

Ceanothus Sequoia Plumbago Betula
Neg Moon (20)Pos Moon (13) Neg Moon (12)Pos Moon (12) Neg Moon (10)Pos Moon (12) Neg Moon (spread)Pos Moon (spread)
Week 1:
5 October
no change no change no change no change no change no change no change no change
Week 2: 12 October no change no change no change no change 1 dead, 5 wilted 2 wilted no change no change
Week 3: 19 October no change no change no change several buds 5 dead 1 shoot 1 sprout no change
Week 4: 26 October no change no change no change 3 buds 5 dead, 3 shoots 5 shoots 1 sprout, off mist no change
Week 5: 5 November no change no change no change 8 buds 5 dead, 3 shoots 5 shoots First true leaf no change
Week 7: 16 November 9 dead (45%) 4 dead (30%) no change Lots of buds 5 dead, 5 shoots 3 dead, 7 shoots First true leaf, 2 more sprouts moved off mist
At this point of the trial, non of the 28 September Sequoias have shown signs of sprouting, while the 30 September Sequoias had new buds all over. When I saw increased activity on the off-mist birch frame, I decided to take the second birch frame off the mist bench. Today I pulled all the dead Plumbago and Ceanothus cuttings.
Week 8: 23 November 9 dead (45%) 4 dead (30%) no change Vigorous growth 5 dead, 5 shoots 3 dead, 7 shoots First true leaf, 2 more sprouts
Week 9: 30 November 9 dead (45%) 4 dead (30%) First 2 buds Vigorous growth 5 dead, 5 shoots 3 dead, 7 shoots First true leaf, 2 more sprouts no sightings, yet
Week 10: 7 December 3 rooted (15%) all dead (0%) Buds on 3 stems (25%) Buds on 8 stems (67%) 5 rooted (50%) 9 rooted (75%) 3 rooted no sightings, yet
On the last class day I transplanted the rooted Ceanothus, Plumbago, and the one birch sprout that had grown the first real leaves. The redwood cuttings didn't show any root growth yet, so I left them in their original cans.
Week 10:
Sequoia shoots without any sign of roots
Week 10:
Plumbago with mighty roots
Week 10:
The little Birch is trying hard
Week 10:
The Birch in its new 4" pot
Week 10:
All survivors in their new homes and ready for the winter

Results and Conclusions

Plumbago

After the first week, there was a slight difference among the Plumbagos: the "Neg Moon" plants showed signs of distress, which after week 3 resulted into 5 dead cuttings. In week 4, the "Pos Moon" Plumbagos had clearly more fresh shoots than their "Neg Moon" siblings. At the end of the experiment, the Plumbagos planted on the beneficial moon day had a 75 percent rooting success vs. 50 percent of the non-beneficial moon plantings.

Ceanothus

Probably due to their dormant period, all cuttings lost most of their leaves and didn't produce any new shoots during the experiment. However, after 10 weeks the only three cuttings that showed some root growth were planted on the non-beneficial moon day.

Sequoia Sempervirens

The redwood cuttings showed the most exciting bud production in the positive moon phase group. 76 percent of the cuttings in this group had produced some buds vs. only 25 percent in the other group. However, non of the cuttings in both groups had produced any root growth.

Birch

The Birch seeds were certainly the most beautiful part of the experiment to watch. The first real leaves were such beautiful and gragile replicas of their big brothers that I couldn't help visiting them more frequently than the cuttings. However, of all birch seeds, only 3 germinated during the 10 week esperiment, and only one had grown real leaves.

Conclusion

Although this experiment is far from statistically significant, the preliminary conclusion could be that Sequoia Sempervirens cuttings and Plumbago cuttings react positively to the biodynamic moon phases, while Ceanothus was at best indifferent. In a subsequent experiment I would start with a greater number of cuttings to achieve more representative results. It would also help to conduct these experiments during different times of the year to respect the different plants' growth cycles.

Back to top.

Valid XHTML 1.0 Strict    Valid CSS!